One Ecosystem :
Research Article
|
Corresponding author: Ivan Kushnov (st084838@student.spbu.ru)
Academic editor: Bastian Steinhoff-Knopp
Received: 15 Nov 2021 | Accepted: 05 Jan 2022 | Published: 10 Jan 2022
© 2022 Evgeny Abakumov, Ivan Kushnov, Timur Nizamutdinov, Rustam Tembotov
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Abakumov E, Kushnov I, Nizamutdinov T, Tembotov R (2022) Cryoconites as biogeochemical markers of anthropogenic impact in high mountain regions: analysis of polyaromatic pollutants in soil-like bodies. One Ecosystem 7: e78028. https://doi.org/10.3897/oneeco.7.e78028
|
|
The globalisation and omnidirectional character of anthropogenic processes has challenged scientists around the world to estimate the harmful effects of these processes on ecosystems and human health. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) is one the most infamous group of contaminants, originated both from natural and anthropogenic processes. They could transport to high latitudes and altitudes through atmospheric long-distance transfer and further enter ecosystems of these vulnerable regions by deposition on terrestrial surfaces. An interesting object for tracking transboundary contamination processes in high mountain ecosystems is called cryoconite. Cryoconite, a dark-coloured supraglacial sediment which is abundant in polar and mountain environments, is considered as a storage of various pollutants, including PAHs. Thus, it may pose a risk for local human health and ecosystem through short-distance transfer. Studied cryoconite sediments were collected at the surface of Skhelda and Garabashi glaciers, Central Caucasus high-mountain region, as well as mudflow, moraine material and local soils at the Baksan Gorge in order to examine levels of their contamination. We analysed the content of 15 priority polyaromatic compounds from the US EPA list and used the method of calculation of PAHs isomer ratios with the purpose of identifying their source. To estimate their potential toxicity, Benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) equivalents were calculated. Maximum concentration was defined for NAP (84 ng×g-1), PHE (40 ng×g-1) and PYR (47 ng×g-1), with the minimum concentration for ANT (about 1 ng×g-1). The most polluted material is a cryoconite from Garabashi glacier because of local anthropogenic activities and long-distance transfer. High-molecular weight PAHs are dominated in PAHs composition of almost all samples. The most common sources of PAHs in studied materials are combustion processes and mixed pyrolytic/petrogenic origin. Toxicity levels of separate PAHs did not exceed the maximum permissible threshold concentrations values in most cases. However, the sum of PAHs in BaP equivalents exceed the threshold values in all samples, in some of them more than twice.
Central Caucasus, glaciers, soils, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, pollution, cryoconite
With the increase of anthropogenic activity on a global scale, the monitoring of various contaminants has become one of the priorities of the world community. One of the most notorious group of these chemicals is polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). PAHs are very common organic pollutants in the environment, consisting of carbon and hydrogen atoms with two or more aromatic rings in their structure (
The potential sources of PAHs release into the environment can be divided into cosmogenic, petrogenic, biogenic and pyrogenic (
After complex transformation, atmospheric PAHs are deposited in water reservoirs, vegetation and soils (
Studies of soil contamination by PAHs is more associated with urban soils due to their proximity to industrial facilities and traffic routes (
Another accumulation object of pollutants in polar and mountain regions is cryoconite. Cryoconite is a widespread black-coloured sediment in supraglacial environments consisting of black carbon, mineral particles, microorganisms and organic matter (
Central Caucasus, as well as other mountain regions, is sensitive to any contamination and disturbance (
The study focused on soil samples, soil-like bodies and cryoconite material sampled in the vicinity of Mount Elbrus and on the surface of the Skhelda and Garabashy glaciers (The Greater Caucasus). The Caucasus Region of Russia is an extremely popular tourist destination (
Year-round, these Caucasus regions are visited by tens of thousands of tourists, which certainly causes anthropogenic pressure on local mountain ecosystems. In this regard, there is a need to track the level of anthropogenic load on ecosystems especially in the areas of famous tourist routes. We conducted research of soils, soil-like bodies and cryoconite material for their PAH content. During the 2020 fieldwork, samples of material from Skhelda and Garabashi glaciers (Fig.
Study site |
Sample ID |
Description |
Coordinates |
Elevation, m |
Sampling date |
Skhelda glacier |
KB 1 |
Material from the slope of the glacier |
|
2385 |
15.09.2020 |
KB 2 |
Cryoconite derived material |
||||
KB 3 |
Material from the slope of the glacier |
||||
Elbrus region, the surroundings of Kendelen Village |
KB 6/1 KB 6/2 |
Chernozems from Kiendelen Village |
|
750 |
16.09.2020 |
The area at the mud-flow |
KB 7/1 |
Mud-flow occurred in 2019 |
|
1490 |
|
KB 7/2 |
|||||
Garabashi glacier |
KB 8 |
The cryoconite from the ice crack of the Garabashi glacier |
|
3860 |
17.09.2020 |
KB 9 |
Cryoconite over ice |
||||
KB 10 |
Moraine sediments on the glacier |
A total of 10 samples were collected, air-dried and transported to the laboratory of the Department of Applied Ecology, St. Petersburg State University. To prevent external contamination, the samples were transported in double sealed plastic bags. The samples were sieved through a sieve with a mesh diameter of 2 mm before preparation for PAH extraction.
Concentrations of 15 high-priority PAHs from the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) list of High Priority Pollutants (excluding acenaphthylene) were conducted (Table
PAH (CAS name) |
Abbr.a |
Molecular Formula |
MWb/Rings |
IARC classification of carcinogenicityc |
CAS no. |
Naphthalene |
NAP |
C12H8 |
128 (2) |
2B |
91–20–3 |
Acenaphthene |
ANA |
C12H10 |
154 (3) |
3 |
83-32-9 |
Fluorene |
FLU |
C13H10 |
166 (3) |
3 |
86-13-7 |
Phenanthrene |
PHE |
C14H10 |
178 (3) |
3 |
85-01-8 |
Anthracene |
ANT |
C14H10 |
178 (3) |
3 |
120-12-7 |
Fluoranthene |
FLT |
C16H10 |
202 (4) |
3 |
206-44-0 |
Pyrene |
PYR |
C16H10 |
202 (4) |
3 |
129-00-0 |
Benzanthracene |
BaA |
C18H12 |
228 (4) |
2B |
56-55-3 |
Chrysene |
CHR |
C18H12 |
228 (4) |
2B |
218-01-9 |
Benz[e]acephenanthrylene |
BbF |
C20H12 |
252 (5) |
2B |
205-99-2 |
Benzo[k]fluoranthene |
BkF |
C20H12 |
252 (5) |
2B |
207-08-9 |
Benzo[a]pyrene |
BaP |
C20H12 |
252 (5) |
1 |
50-32-08 |
Dibenz[a,h]anthracene |
DBA |
C22H14 |
278 (5) |
2A |
53-70-3 |
Benzo[ghi]perylene |
BPE |
C22H12 |
276 (6) |
3 |
191-24-2 |
Indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene |
IPY |
C22H12 |
276 (6) |
2B |
193-39-5 |
a- used in this article; b - molecular weight;c - 1 - Carcinogenic to humans; 2A - Probably carcinogenic to humans; 2B - Possibly carcinogenic to humans; 3 - Not classifiable as to its carcinogenicity to humans |
Extraction of PAHs from soil was performed using diethyl ether (
Since PAHs can be formed not only as a result of technogenic processes, but can also be generated by various natural processes, it is possible to use PAHs as markers for anthropogenic impact. The origin of PAHs can be determined by applying different PAH diagnostic (isomer) ratios (
Isomeric ratios are widely used by researchers to identify the nature of the origin of PAHs and we have analysed the literature and selected several ratios (Table
PAHs isomer ratios |
Range of values |
Possible sources of PAH |
References |
ANT / (ANT + PHE) |
< 0.10 |
Petroleum/Baseline source |
|
> 0.10 |
Indicates a dominance of combustion |
||
FLU / (FLU + PYR) |
< 0.40 |
Most petroleum/Baseline source |
|
0.40-0.50 |
Liquid fossil fuel (vehicle and crude oil) combustion |
||
> 0.50 |
Characteristic of grass, wood or coal combustion |
||
BaA / (BaA + CHR) |
< 0.20 |
Petroleum/Baseline source |
|
0.20-0.35 |
Petroleum, combustion, baseline source |
||
> 0.35 |
Combustion |
||
PHE / ANT |
> 10 |
Petrogenic |
|
< 10 |
Pyrolytic |
||
FLU / PYR |
< 1.0 |
Petrogenic |
|
> 1.0 |
Pyrolytic |
||
BaP / BPE |
< 0.60 |
Non-traffic source |
|
> 0.60 |
Traffic source |
||
∑PyrPAHsa /∑15PAHs |
< 0.30 |
Petroleum/Baseline source |
|
0.30-0.70 |
Petroleum, combustion, baseline source |
||
> 0.70 |
Mostly combustion |
||
∑LMWPAHsb /∑HMWPAHsc |
< 1 |
Pyrogenic |
|
> 1 |
Petrogenic |
||
a - pyrogenic PAHs - FLT, PYR, BaA, CHR, BbF, BkF, BaP, BPE, IPY, b - light molecular weight, 2-3 ring PAHs, c - heavy molecular weight HMW, 4-6 ring PAHs |
Most PAHs are poorly understood in terms of their carcinogenesis and mutagenic effects on the human body. However, Benzo[a]pyrene is well studied and is recognised as one of the most toxic PAHs. Therefore, many studies are conducted by comparing the toxicity levels of various PAHs in relation to Benzo[a]pyrene, in other words, by calculating Benzo[a]pyrene equivalents (BaP – equivalents) of the toxicity of PAHs (
The use of equivalents also makes it possible to compare detected PAH concentrations with various standards, for example, in Russia, the maximum permissible concentration (MPC) of Benzo[a]pyrene in soils is 0.02 mg×kg-1 (
This approach makes it possible to assess not only the carcinogenic effects of single PAHs, but also to cite the level of exposure to total concentrations of various PAHs to the level of exposure to Benzo[a]pyrene. BaP – equivalents were calculated by multiplying the values of carcinogenic equivalency factors (TEF) and recorded concentrations of individual PAHs (
The concentrations of recorded PAHs are shown in Fig.
Fig.
We carried out a cluster analysis of the obtained matrix of concentrations of individual PAHs by Ward's method using the Euclidean distance as a metric (
In addition, we performed statistical processing of the data to observe differences in PAH content in anthropogenically loaded cryoconites, soils and conditionally pristine cryoconites. As can be seen (Table
The highest concentration of the ∑15PAHs is detected in the sample taken at point KB8 (280 ng×g-1), in other samples the content of the ∑15PAHs is much lower (126 – 151 ng×g-1) (Fig.
Summary of concentrations of different PAH groups.
∑HMWPAHs – FLT, PYR, BaA, CHR, BbF, BkF, BaP, DBA, BPE, IPY.
∑LMWPAHs – NAP, ANA, FLU, PHE, ANT.
∑pyrPAHs – FLT, PYR, BaA, CHR, BbF, BkF, BaP, BPE, IPY.
∑carcPAHs – NAP, BaA, CHR, BbF, BkF, BaP, DBA, BPE, IPY
A more detailed analysis of the contribution of different groups of PAHs to the ∑15PAHs (Fig.
The application of indicator (isomer) ratios of concentrations of individual PAHs has shown quite interesting results about the possible sources of PAHs. Fig.
The PHE/ANT ratio value indicates a possible petrogenic source of PAHs in samples KB6/2, KB8, and KB10 (ratio values <10). For all other investigated samples, the sources of PAHs are pyrolytic processes (value <10). The value of the FLU/PYR ratio (similar to FLU/(FLU + PYR)) indicates the petrogenic (baseline) origin of these PAHs (value <1.0). The origin of BaP and BPE, as can be seen from the value of their ratios, is predominantly of a non-traffic nature. Only for the KB8 sample, the possible source of these PAHs is traffic. The wider and more complex isomer ratios as ∑PyrPAHs/∑15PAHs and ∑LMWPAHs/∑HMWPAHs indicate a mixed and pyrogenic source of the studied PAHs.
The construction of cross-sectional graphs (bi-plots) of isomeric ratios allows a more detailed study of the possible sources of PAHs (Fig.
Cross-analysis of FLU/(FLU + PYR) and ANT/(ANT + PHE) ratios shows that these PAHs in samples KB8, KB6/2, KB9, KB6/1 and KB1 are of petrogenic (baseline) source. For the remaining samples, the possible source of these PAHs is combustion processes. A similar check for the ratios ∑LMWPAHs/∑HMWPAHs and BaA/(BaA + CHR) indicates a pyrolytic source of PAHs in all samples except KB8, which shows a mixed source.
The calculation of BaP-equivalents has shown (Fig.
Concentrations of studied PAHs in BaP-equivalents.
MPC – maximum permissible concentration of BaP in soil (in Russian Legislation)
When converting the sum of PAHs to BaP-equivalents, we can see (Fig.
Currently, rapid deglaciation is observed in most of the mountain regions of the world. This process is also pronounced in the Central Caucasus area, where about 94% of glaciers are retreating (
It was previously thought that the concentration of PAHs in soils and sediments is connected with anthropogenic pressure in the surrounding area. Contamination levels of sediments in the China Sea decreased while moving to the south, away from the more industrialised northern part of China with higher levels of atmospheric emissions (
In previous research at the Tibetan Plateau (
The calculation of isomeric ratios and construction of cross-sectional graphs show that PAHs entered the Elbrus Region with atmospheric winds, as well as due to local anthropogenic activities. We conducted several calculations of isomeric ratios; however, the most reliable are less wide and less complex due to possible differences in transformation of PAHs compounds in various environmental conditions (
Constructed bi-plots give us a mostly similar view on the sources of PAHs. Most of them indicate a pyrolytic source, associated with traffic, in all of the studied samples with the exception of KB8, which shows a mixed genesis. There is a similar result, obtained from calculation of ∑LMWPAHs/∑HMWPAHs isomeric ratios. Here, we can say that KB8 is the most polluted sample due to both deposition of the polluted material from the atmosphere, coming mostly from the Mesopotamia Region and closeness to the local anthropogenic pollution sources. The constructed cross plots of diagnostic ratios for cryoconite in the Tibetan Plateau showed the main source of PAHs was combustion of biomass, coal and fossil fuels, including traffic (
For estimation of potential toxicity, BaP-equivalence calculation has been conducted due to the fact that not all of the studied pollutants have a maximum permissible concentration (MPC). The method of BaP-equivalence calculation has a long practice and is applied all over the world. It is tightly connected with the calculation of TEF and toxic equivalent concentration (TEQ) (
It is well known that climate change in high-mountain regions is more pronounced than the global average (
As can be seen from this work, the role of cryoconites as biogeochemical markers can be used. The conducted study shows the contamination of cryoconite, soils and some other materials by 15 high-priority polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. The highest contamination levels were defined for NAP (84 ng×g-1), PHE (40 ng×g-1) and PYR (47 ng×g-1), the lowest was defined for ANT (about 1 ng×g-1). The most polluted material is a cryoconite from Garabashi glacier (∑15PAHs = 280 ng×g-1) which is a result of both local anthropogenic activities and long-distance transfer. Amongst most of all studied samples, HMW PAHs are dominating with the exception of the most polluted point which indicates mixed input of PAHs, local petroleum leaks and closeness to vehicles emissions. The most common sources of PAHs in studied materials are combustion processes and mixed pyrolytic/petrogenic origin. Local anthropogenic influence is associated with tourism development, while long-distance transfer is probably connected with combustion of biomass and shipping routes. Toxicity levels of separate polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons did not exceed the maximum permissible concentration values in most cases. On the other hand, the sum of PAHs in BaP equivalents exceeded the threshold values in all samples, where some of them were twice higher. It was found that contamination of cryoconite may affect the toxicity levels of soils at the foothills through transfer of material by water streams. Thus, further research is required to understand the impact of PAHs on the vulnerable environment of the Central Caucasus mountain region.
Russian Foundation for Basic Research, project No. 19-05-50107.
E. A. conceptualised the article, I. K. wrote the article, T. N. performed analysis of the data, R. T. sampled studied materials and contributed to the interpretation of the results. All authors discussed the results and commented on the manuscript.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.