One Ecosystem :
Research Article
|
Corresponding author: Elena Rumenova Todorova (elenatyukenova@yahoo.com)
Academic editor: Stoyan Nedkov
Received: 02 Feb 2023 | Accepted: 22 Feb 2023 | Published: 15 Mar 2023
© 2023 Elena Todorova, Miglena Zhiyanski
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Todorova ER, Zhiyanski MK (2023) Study on soil quality in different functional zones of Sofia region. One Ecosystem 8: e101381. https://doi.org/10.3897/oneeco.8.e101381
|
|
The present study deals with examining the condition of urban soils and their potential to deliver soil-related regulating ecosystem services concerning the level of anthropogenic pressure in different functional zones of Sofia, Bulgaria. Analyses of data for selected characteristics of superficial 0-10 cm soil layer of urban soils were performed. Soils were sampled from 30 experimental plots within a geo-referred network covering urban and peri-urban territories. The concentrations of heavy metals Cu, Zn, Pb and Fe were analysed to determine the level of pollution, while soil pH, cation-exchange capacity (CEC), total carbon and total nitrogen content were used as indicators for assessing the regulating ecosystem service “soil quality”. The results demonstrate the differences in the potential of four functional zones – green zones, industrial zones, residential zones and zones for urban agriculture, to regulate and maintain “soil quality”. The purpose of the assessment is to outline the zones with the potential for implicating mitigation measures in urban and peri-urban zones, based on maps of soil quality, which contributes to focusing more attention on the protection and restoration of urban soils, to reduce soil pollution and to increase the reuse of urban soils.
soils, anthropogenic pressure, urban ecology, assessment, spatial analysis, maps
Nowadays, cities continue to evolve and grow in size, complexity and in significance. The continuous concentration of people in the urban formations provokes scientists’ attention, broadening the interest towards integration of newly-developed concepts within the urban management, planning and protection of natural resources. Connecting the elements and considering the constant mutual interaction between the city and nature gives birth to the notion of urban ecosystems. As
Soils are the fundamental component of terrestrial ecosystems and are widely distributed, easily accessible and easily wasted (
The concept of soil quality is considered to transcend the productivity of soils (
Following the recent tendencies of ecological studies in urban environments, the present study deals with examining soil quality in the region of Sofia within the context of assessment and mapping the potential of urban ecosystems to provide the regulating ecosystem service “soil quality”. The territory of interest is divided into four functional zones - green zones, industrial zones, residential zones and zones for urban agriculture, following the existing studies of urban ecosystem services (
Sofia is located in the Sofia Valley at the foot of the Vitosha Mountain in the western parts of Bulgaria and, within its administrative borders, it covers an area of 492 km² (
The
The soil sampling was realised in 2011 on the territory of Sofia region covering the city and its surroundings. The soil samples were collected by coring in five points for each experimental plot in three soil depths: 0-10; 10-30; and 30-50 cm, but, in the present study, only the superficial soil layer is discussed. Although heavy metal content in soils could be related to soil parent material composition, the contribution from anthropogenic sources affects superficial soil layers; therefore, the determination of heavy metals content was focused on the superficial soil (0-10 cm depth) as the indicator for anthropogenic pressure effect on soil condition.
The soil samples were analysed for textural composition (pipette method titration with hydrochloric acid - HCl), pH (potentiometrically), carbon content (Corg.) according to the Turin method, for total nitrogen (N) according to Kjeldahl and cation-exchange capacity (CEC) according to
The grid with the experimental plots and the results from the samples provide information about the condition of urban soils in different functional zones (Fig.
To distribute the data from the soil sampling and relate it to data for the ecosystem service “soil quality”, provided by the functional zones, the possibilities of the geographic information systems (GIS) for spatial reference and interpolation were used. The combination of data different in their genesis and characteristics provide opportunities for solving different types of research problems (
Identification of functional zones in Sofia linked to the Methodology for assessment and mapping of urban ecosystems condition and their services in Bulgaria sub-types.
The territory of Sofia region is, thus, differentiated in these four functional zones and each of them is attributed to the scores obtained for the soil quality. Interpolation was applied for matching the range of the terrain data with the range of the functional areas. The Inverse Distance Weighted (IDW) technique was used to compute an average value for unsampled locations, based on values from nearby weighted locations. The weights are proportional to the proximity of the sampled points to the unsampled location and can be specified by the IDW power coefficient (
Specific features of chemical soil properties in urban areas are contamination with heavy metals and alkalisation (
Indicator | 1 Very bad | 2 Bad | 3 Medium | 4 Good | 5 Very Good |
Cu (mg/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
Zn (mg/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
Pb (mg/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
Fe (mg/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
C (g/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
N (g/kg) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
CEC (meq/100g) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
pH (H2O) | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… | ……… |
The assessment of each indicator was therefore summed and the mean value is used in populating the matrix for the needs and supply of ecosystem services, suggested by
Matrix for total assessment of the functional zones after
Functional zone | C (g/kg) | N (g/kg) | pH (H2O) | CEC (meq/100g) | Evaluation |
Green zone | …. | …. | …. | …. | …. |
Industrial zone | …. | …. | …. | …. | …. |
Residential area | …. | …. | …. | …. | …. |
Urban Agriculture | …. | …. | …. | …. | …. |
The indicators are evaluated in a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 shows the worst assessment that the indicator receives. The values of the indicators are classified in five equal intervals. These values are also juxtaposed to the Safety concentrations and Maximum permissible concentrations as regulated in Regulation No. 3 (
The results from the present study show no exceedance of the safety concentrations and the Maximum permissible concentrations as regulated in Regulation No. 3 for Cu and Zn. The results obtained for the sampled soils show exceedance of the permissible concentration (45 mg/kg) for Pb for 24 out of the 30 experimental plots and four of them are on the verge of the Maximum permissible concentrations of 130 mg/kg.
To determine the level of anthropogenic pressure on soils in the studied functional zones, the results for heavy metals concentrations were differentiated and interpolated by using IDW interpolation and dissemination of the outcome by functional zones that include the green zone, industrial zone, residential zone and urban agriculture. The scores of indicators for anthropogenic pressure are visualised as consolidated results for each of the heavy metals, including data for the main soil pollutants as determined in the Environmental analysis in the Programme for Sofia (
Evaluation scores of heavy metals content in urban soils as indicators for anthropogenic pressure in the region of Sofia.
Indicator | 1 Very bad | 2 Bad | 3 Medium | 4 Good | 5 Very Good |
Cu (mg/kg) | 60.01 - 140.00 | 40.01 - 60.00 | 20.01 - 40.00 | 15.01 - 20.00 | 9.34 - 15.00 |
Zn (mg/kg) | 160.1 - 180 | 120.1 - 160 | 80.01 - 120 | 60.01 - 80 | 52.37 - 60 |
Pb (mg/kg) | 45.01 - 129.8 | 42.92 - 45 | 40.43 - 42.91 | 37.89 - 40.42 | 35.09 - 37.88 |
Fe (mg/kg) | 25780 - 29650 | 21910 - 25770 | 18030 - 21900 | 14160 - 18020 | 10270 - 14150 |
The intervals correspond to the maximum permissible concentration of the heavy metals acceding to Regulation No. 3 оn the standards for permissible content of harmful substances in soils (
Copper (Cu) could influence the fertility of the soil. Cu is not particularly mobile in the soil and only a small part of this element is absorbed by plants. The natural behaviour of copper in soils is to be concentrated in the surface due to its tendency to complex with organic matter (
Accumulation of Cu (mg/kg) in the soils from functional zones of Sofia. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The concentration of iron (Fe) varied from 10270 mg/kg to 29650 mg/kg. The highest concentration is detected in the residential territories and the lowest – in the industrial and green zones, but the range of the values is small. The values of this indicator vary from high to low in all the functional zones and no clear pattern of distribution could be determined. The range of concentration values indicates a relatively low level of pollution with iron in the studied region. It could be summarised that the iron content in the superficial urban soil layer is within the limits and without exceedance of safety concentrations (Fig.
Accumulation of Fe (mg/kg) in the soils in functional zones of Sofia. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The values for accumulation of Lead (Pb) range from 35 mg/kg to 130 mg/kg, which exceeds the safety concentrations of 45 mg/kg and is on the verge of the Maximum permissible concentrations. Only limited territories for urban agriculture show lower accumulation of Pb. Therefore, Pb appears to be defined as one of the main pollutants in urban soils in Sofia and needs special attention (Fig.
Accumulation of Pb (mg/kg) in the soils of functional zones in Sofia. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The accumulation of zinc (Zn) varies from 52 to 130 mg/kg, keeping it below the safety concentrations, but still with predominantly high values. All the functional zones include both minimum and maximum values. No specific pattern could be determined for the distribution of that indicator. The peri-urban territories that are designated for urban agriculture show lower values of Zn accumulation, except for two locations, which are situated directly next to the industrial zones (Fig.
To complete the research task, the relationship between the functional zone and the indicators for soil quality was also investigated.
The evaluation of the indicators of soil quality is based on scoring their values, including C, N and pH and CEC, following the matrix presented in Table 4 and disseminating the results into equal intervals that are evaluated with grades from 1 (very bad) to 5 (very good) (Table
Indicator | 1 Very bad | 2 Bad | 3 Medium | 4 Good | 5 Very Good |
C (g/kg) | 0.74 - 1.45 | 1.46 - 2.02 | 2.03 - 2.59 | 2.60 - 3.17 | 3.18 - 5.04 |
CEC (meq/100g) | 26.40 - 32.74 | 32.75 - 39.08 | 39.09 - 45.42 | 45.43 - 51.76 | 51.77 - 58.1 |
pH (g/kg) | 7.74 - 8.41 | 7.58 - 7.74 | 6.51 - 7.57 | 6.42 - 6.5 | 6.37- 6.41 |
N (g/kg) | 0.08 - 0.1 | 0.11 - 0.12 | 0.13 - 0.14 | 0.15 - 0.16 | 0.17 - 0.18 |
The intervals were used to assess the dissemination of the indicators in the territory of Sofia region.
Acidity (pH) of studied urban soils varied from 6.37 to 8.41, which refer to the neutral-alkaline soils. pH plays an important role in the stabilisation of organic matter. Furthermore, total heavy metal concentrations in the soil correlate positively with pH. This correlation is highly specific for every metal compound and highly influenced by the existence of oxygen, organic matter and soil textural fractions (especially clay minerals) (
Soil pH distributed by functional zones in Sofia. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The carbon content in studied urban soils is low to very low compared to the surrounding natural soils. The lowest concentration of C is observed in the eastern part of Sofia. The peri-urban territories are distinguished by the highest concentrations. In the urban territory, the green zones and the residential zones share similar values for this parameter (Fig.
Accumulation of C (g/kg) in the soils of functional zones in Sofia. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
CEC is a useful indicator for soil fertility and, in experimental plots, it varies from 27.71 to 56.4 meq/100g. Soils, having a high CEC, change pH much more slowly. CEC is linked to the organic carbon content, clay content and type of land-use and management. Again, there is a tendency for lower values in the eastern part of Sofia and values over 30 meq/100g in the peri-urban territory are confirmed (Fig.
CEC (meq/100g) in the soils in Sofia distributed by functional zones. *Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The pattern of distribution of the total nitrogen is very like the pattern of distribution of carbon, nitrogen, CEC and soils with higher pH. For all parameters, characterising the soil quality, the same geographical pattern of poor characteristics to the east and good in the peri-urban territory is observed. The distribution within the four functional zones has no clearly defined spatial pattern (Fig.
Accumulation of N (g/kg) in the soils in Sofia distributed by functional zones. * Source of the wind rose – Meteoblue. Source of basemap – Google Maps.
The simple matrix was completed to assess the potential of urban functional zones to sustain “soil quality”. The evaluation of each parameter by zone was summed and the mean value of the soil quality was aggregated. The results are presented in Table
Evaluation of the potential of urban functional zones to provide ecosystem service “soil quality”.
Ecosystem service Soil quality |
C | CEC | pH | N | Total Evaluation | Mean |
Green zone | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 10 | 2.5 |
Industrial zone | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 7 | 1.75 |
Residential area | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 8 | 2 |
Urban Agriculture | 4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 14 | 3.5 |
The soil quality parameters in the urban zone show rather ‘bad’ soil quality in the residential and industrial zone, medium potential in green zones and good potential in zones for urban agriculture. As visible from the maps, the eastern regions show lower quality (Table
Ecosystem service Urban Functional Zone |
Cu | Zn | Pb | Fe | Total Evaluation | Mean |
Green zone | 4 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 12 | 3.08 |
Industrial zone | 3 | 4 | 2 | 3 | 11 | 2.81 |
Residential area | 3 | 4 | 1 | 3 | 11 | 2.77 |
Urban Agriculture | 3 | 4 | 2 | 1 | 12 | 2.89 |
The anthropogenic pressure is assessed as medium in all functional zones, which demonstrates the effect of pollution on the overall urbanised region of Sofia including both urban and peri-urban territories. The scores for concentrations of Pb are poor and reduce the general score leading to worse overall evaluation.
A parallel between the soil quality and the condition of functional zones in terms of the anthropogenic pressure effect could be drawn. Green zones and urban agriculture zones have better overall evaluation than the residential and industrial zones and still have medium to good potential to sustain soil quality. It could be underlined that the demarcation is minimal and the scores have close values. The assessment shows that the soil quality is well provided by green zones and urban agricultural zones. Considering the overall anthropogenic pressure and the observed geographical patterns in the studied region of Sofia, the green infrastructure and peri-urban zones have the potential to contribute to a better condition of the soils through improvement of the main soil parameters.
Considering the assessment of the functional zones in Sofia, better potential in maintaining soil quality is determined for green zones and zones for urban agriculture versus residential and industrial zones, which are characterised by low potential.
Good management of soils is fundamental in providing economic, socio-cultural and environmental benefits for the population and all communities in urbanised areas. According to the
Urban soils are one of the dynamically changing factors, which directly relate to the other components of ecosystems and are characterised by a high adsorbing and accumulating effect in terms of both pollutants (
For the studied heavy metals (Cu, Zn, Pb, Fe), anthropogenic sources play a more important role in the global geochemical cycle of these elements than natural sources (
The results obtained for the accumulation of copper, zinc, lead and iron in the superficial soil layers in selected experimental plots in Sofia region confirm these findings and the negative effect of anthropogenic pressure on soils in ecosystems from all functional zones. As a result, it could be summarised that no specific pattern for the concentration of toxic metals in the urban territory has been determined, dependent on the functional zonation. Most of the indicators vary in the same range, regardless of whether they are in the residential, industrial or green zone. This brings us to the notion that green infrastructure is already affected by anthropogenic pressure and is threatened by difficulties maintaining the balance for a healthy ecosystem in the future. A trend that could be determined is that there is a ubiquitous concentration of Pb and Zn in the superficial soil layer which indicates contamination from anthropogenic activity. A possible reason for that circumstance may be that the local contamination from quarries and metallurgy from the past has spread over time and continue to cause ecological problems. This is a problem that needs attention and comparative studies.
The soil component is a very sensitive reflector of the condition of the urban ecosystem, as it is the backbone of many of the processes that keep its functionality. The quality of the soils in the functional zones in Sofia region determines the delivery of soil-related ecosystem services. The historical contamination of urban soils in Sofia originates from the anthropogenic activities related to intensive urbanisation combined with heavy industry, transport and local heating. Nowadays, the pressure on the urban ecosystems is still high compared to the natural territories; therefore, urban green zones play a significant role in provisioning a set of ecosystem services for the local population. The analyses of the parameters of soil quality in Sofia region show that the current condition in the green zones ensures the potential to supply ecosystem services, which is relatively higher than the potential in residential and industrial functional zones, but not so well expressed. Thus, the anthropogenic pressure over green spaces has already affected, to some extent, the capacity of urban forest parks to maintain good “soil quality” and functioning of ecosystems. On the contrary, the peri-urban areas used for urban agriculture still have a higher potential to supply good soil quality and could be used effectively. Considering that the anthropogenic pressure has a constant upward trend and that the negative consequences accumulate over time, the management of urban green zones faces the risk of malfunctioning or worsening the condition of urban forest parks in the future, because of the little attention paid to the soil quality. The increasing anthropogenic pressure, combined with the threats from climate change needs a deeper knowledge of the structure and functioning of the urban ecosystem and an urgent new management approach, based on knowledge of soil condition. Better maintenance of the green spaces and the application of appropriate management practices that consider soil quality as an important factor for the urban ecosystem balance are possible solutions for this challenge. This is directly linked to the need to include new approaches in management and a legislative basis for urban areas and urban forestry, which consider specific measures for improving soil-related ecosystem services.
National Science Programme “Environmental Protection and Reduction of Risks of Adverse Events and Natural Disasters”, approved by the Resolution of the Council of Ministers No. 577/17.08.2018 and supported by the Ministry of Education and Science (MES) of Bulgaria (Agreement No. D01-271/09.12.2022).